An aspect of the irrationality of eco-warriors

Eco-warriors are interesting creatures. They are portrayed by the media as the saviours of our planet and get sympathetic treatment all-round because they ‘mean well’; yet many of them haven’t a clue what they really stand for and know nothing about the underlying scientific arguments behind the perceived problem. Though a sceptic myself about anthropogenic global warming, I still respect true scientists who have devoted time to research the issue and decided, independently of peer pressure and media attention, that they believe humans are having a damaging effect on the environment. However I just cannot bring myself to respect the one-sided eco-warrior who has never, and owing to obstinacy never will, hear the other side of the argument, and who, when asked about what evidence there is, flies into a rage and accuses the inquirer of being a sceptic who wants to see the world burn in hell.

The thing about eco-warriors is, as Theo pointed out in a comment to my post on Transport in London, that there is a certain level of idealism involved. It’s interesting that many of them believe electric cars are the solution. OK I admit it’s not true they’re ‘slow and pointless’ – in fact there was a fairly sleek one at the motor show at ExCel recently which had similar specs to a normal fast car in terms of speed, acceleration etc. (fine, about 3 times the price but still…). However the practical aspects are horrifically complicated yet hugely overlooked and few people seem to understand what will happen at about 5pm when all the electric cars recharge at once. England’s electricity infrastructure is crumbly enough as it is, and with a growing energy demand it has been predicted that the recent brown outs will be a regular occurrence in the future. And to be honest I don’t think British Energy is focussed enough on increasing Britain’s electricity production which merely exacerbates the problem; I suspect the company was simply too busy selling out to EDF (and now possibly Centrica) to bother about long-term plans and development, particularly in the area of nuclear energy, which was what EDF was originally supposed to bring.

So in short, the point I’m really making here is that the media and the green community simply do not understand the issue and as a result of their naïveté seem to have blown the perceived problem of man-made global warming so out of proportion that desperate proposed solutions have become positively nonsensical, and that those very nonsensical solutions are getting an uncomfortably wide audience which I fear may result in the future in a disaster which would have been so easily evitable.

Advertisements

One Response to An aspect of the irrationality of eco-warriors

  1. Theo says:

    I’d like to see myself as a negative optimist, or a positive pessimist ( which sounds better cos of alliteration :| ), but I totally agree that this whole situation is blowing out of control. Changes will happen to our Earth’s climate in the next 200 years, or even 30 years: but the climate has been changing for 4.6 billion years, ever since the Earth started life as a fiery lump of rock forged out of the sun or what-not. Humans are not the sole contributor to the Earth’s climate, even though eco-activists seem to think so. I like your point about the fact that electricty demand will sky-rocket at around 5pm after work if everyone had electric cars. Even at the moment, as a BBC programme pointed out, as the Eastenders theme tune begins to play at the end of an episode of the frankly brilliant soap (personal opinion), we have to take some electricity from France to deal with the demand from kettles being turned on.
    Anyways, I hope eco-activists learn to look at both sides of the argument,a nd that’ll be better for all the rest of us.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: